Sudden phrase-initial beat-long cutoffs

I have literally no idea how to describe this in words, but here's a short list of a bunch of songs that do a cool musical thing.

• A Cruel Angel's Thesis (theme song of Neon Genesis Evangelion)

  First listen to this pre-chorus bit (this is not the cool musical thing), and in particular listen for the electronic brassy thing at about the midpoint, on the first syllable of "moshimo":

  Now keep that little sound effect in mind, and listen for it at the beginning of the chorus (around 0:04):

  That's the cool thing! The electronic brassy thing doesn't happen on beat 1, like expected; it stops abruptly and comes in on beat 2 instead. The surprise effect is further amplified by the three notes on the same instrument strongly leading up to beat 1, which makes you really anticipate hearing:

  

  Compare this to the second time that musical phrase happens in the chorus, at around 0:10-0:11. There, the same instrument has a similar run that actually lands on beat 1 this time. This makes sense, since it'd feel overdone / cheesy / lose its impact if it happened every time. (There is still a small remnant of the beat 2 landing, in the form of a cymbal crash.)

  This is the song that originally inspired me to make this list, which is interesting, because it sort of leaves out the "cutoff" part of the title of this post. So the next example is the most dramatic one in that regard.

• Flowers (unreasonably catchy song by Miley Cyrus)

  This song does the thing into each chorus, and it sounds a little different each time:

  Hopefully this one is striking enough that I don't need to say anything more! I like how each time gets progressively more dramatic -- the first has an audible breath on beat 1, but the second and third are completely silent, and the third changes up the rhythm of the drums leading into it.

• The Middle (the only song by Jimmy Eat World that anyone's ever heard)

  This song has a cool variation where instead of everything cutting out, all the instrumentals cut out, leaving just the solo vocals on beat 1. It's a really neat effect:

  Kind of like the Evangelion song, this one accentuates the same beat 2 in every other measure with a cymbal crash (and the same sixteenths on the drums leading up to the preceding 1).

• Believer (by Imagine Dragons, of Murder on the Orient Express-movie-trailer fame)

  This one is quite in-your-face about it.

  Like the last one, it's not "complete silence on 1" but rather "all parts except one drop out on 1"; in this case, it's the low bass rumble. It's also maybe two beats, I dunno, you could count this song in 4 or 2 or 12, but it's the same idea.

• Mor Ardain - Roaming the Wastes (from the Xenoblade Chronicles 2 OST)

  The first time this particular melody appears, followed by the one where it does the thing:

  While some of these examples have had all but one part doing the cutoff (The Middle, Believer) and some of these have had only one part doing the cutoff (Evangelion), this one is kind of in the middle -- half of the band is playing the pickups and continues into the melody as normal, and the other half comes crashing in on beat 2 echoing the main melody's beat 1. There's also a nice piano gliss on the 1 of that measure to accentuate the whole effect.

  I've edited this example in 9 months after the original post because it actually came up "in the wild" -- in the MIT Video Game Orchestra we're playing an arrangement of this piece, and one of our conductors (who made the arrangement) specifically stopped to point this out (to which I was mentally screaming "yes!!! it's the thing!!").

Can you think of any other songs that do this? I would be interested to know!

comments